Pizza restaurants

Buck's Pizza - Madison

4.6 252 reviews 04:00 PM - 08:45 PM 219 Cottage Grove Rd, Madison, WI 53716, United States

Discover this place

Buck's Pizza is a local pizza restaurant located at 219 Cottage Grove Rd in Madison, Wisconsin. The establishment specializes in thin crust pizzas, crafted with their signature Buck's Pizza dough. The menu offers classic options such as a 14-inch Pepperoni Pizza and a 14-inch Cheese Pizza, alongside combinations featuring sausage, mushrooms, and olives. Known for its takeout-only service, Buck's Pizza provides a straightforward and convenient dining experience. The focus remains on delivering consistently well-balanced flavors with a crispy crust, fresh toppings, and a blend of cheeses that complement the thin base. The atmosphere is casual, catering primarily to customers who prefer to enjoy their pizza at home or nearby venues. Buck's Pizza maintains its identity as a neighborhood spot with a legacy that resonates within the Madison community through its simple yet carefully prepared offerings.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Onsite services
Takeout

Highlights

Fast service

Popular for

Dinner

Dining options

Dinner
Counter service
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Buck's Pizza - Madison before visiting.

Reviews for Buck's Pizza - Madison

4.6

252 reviews

100%

14%

Review highlights

Based on 252 reviews

Buck's Pizza in Madison, WI, is widely praised for its consistently excellent thin and crispy crust, which forms the cornerstone of its appeal. Customers frequently highlight the perfect balance of fresh, high-quality toppings and a well-blended cheese and sauce combination. The restaurant's takeout-only model is noted, with patrons appreciating the convenience and flavor retention of their pizzas despite this limitation. Buck's Pizza also fosters a strong sense of tradition and loyalty among its guests, often associated with special occasions and cherished memories. While primarily focused on takeout, the brand benefits from a welcoming nearby atmosphere where customers can enjoy their meals. Overall, Buck's Pizza maintains a reputation for delivering reliably delicious, satisfying pizzas with a focus on quality ingredients and a distinctive thin crust that continues to resonate with both locals and visitors alike.

Ken Schneider

May 18, 2025

This is the place my dad took me just down the street to when I was very young. Driving home with a hot pizza on my lap. I lost my dad when I was 8 and Im 57 now. This pizza is incredibly good. Its my special occasion pizza! Best thin crust pizza I have found. I get them "par-baked" and finish cooking at home. Save your receipts-11th pizza is FREE!

Dana Casey

May 10, 2025

Every time we have picked up at Bucks it has been an amazing experience! Greatest crispy crust, perfect amount & blend of cheeses, we love, love it with sausage & jalapeno. We can't wait to get home to eat it! Something about Bucks consistently amazing!

Christina

May 01, 2025

I can't say enough good things about bucks! This is easily one of our favorite pizzas in Madison. Thin crust quality toppings great cheese, every time we get them they are just a treat. Heads up that they are take out only but it is absolutely worth it. If you want to try them but can't do the takeout option the Jade Monkey right next door is perfectly fine with you bringing the pizza in there and eating. And Jade monkey and Buck's Pizza makes a great combination

Torina Fraboni

Apr 30, 2025

Absolutely delicious pizzas. Got pizza for the first time and I’m so jacked to order again soon. The crust was thin and crispy and the ratio of toppings and sauce and cheese was perfect.

Burt Amos

Apr 20, 2025

I’m from Chicago and frequent Madison to visit. Excellent thin and crispy crust! Sauce was good and savory. Toppings were fresh and tasty.

Mike Bojko

Apr 06, 2025

Delicious! Sauce so good, makes me want to rub it all over my body and dance. That cracker thin crust allows me to eat a full large pie. Bucks is a thick Italian queen that gives a good suck. :) my belly is oh so full

Christopher Kuhlers

Mar 25, 2025

Easily the best carry-out style of pizza in town. Make sure to check their website for coupons, otherwise they're on the high side of prices.

Megan Sandridge

Mar 19, 2025

We love Buck's Pizza. Every time I come up from KC, I always have to stop and get my husband a pizza to bring home. We always just get a large cheese. There have been times when we have stayed for an extended time up there, and I took them my own vegan cheese blend, and they made me a vegan pizza that way. Next time I go up to Madison, I will be doing that again. It's a must stop. My family also loves their pepperoni.